Quantity vs Quality

Extensive applications arising from the theory of information have been made in the obvious areas, such as television channels, telephone lines, and computer networks. However, information theory's applications in such frontier areas as speech processing, speech synthesis and recognition, optical-character recognition, music synthesis, and so on, are of even greater interest. Information Theory for Technologists by M J Usher (see reference4) contains a summary of these applications.

One shortcoming of information theory is its restriction to the efficient transmission of messages without any regard for their meaning. For instance, a choice between two equally probable messages has an information content of 1 infobit, but the significance of the messages may be vastly different from a human point of view. For example, there is a vast difference in significance between the two messages "rain tomorrow" and "no rain tomorrow", and the two messages "earthquake tomorrow" and "no earthquake tomorrow".

Saying that information theory deals only with the quantity of information and not its quality may be valid criticism. However, Shannon carefully pointed out that the theory was concerned only with the efficient transmission of messages and not with their semantics. Originally, the theory of probability dealt only with the chances of alternative events. In due course, it was extended to handle the relative values of the different events by incorporating the ideas of profits and losses associated with the outcomes. Similar extensions may arise as information theory is applied more and more to the frontier areas.

The qualitative implications of information theory, the implications of redundancy, and how these ideas have found application in areas much wider than the transmission of information are discussed in a fascinating book by Jeremy Campbell, Grammatical Man (see reference 5).